Past Events

 

ems

Corporte Site

Forward this page to a friendPrint Page View

Montecristo Number 2


Jimmy McGhee




I have just finished smoking one these this morning and, once again, I am left with the thought that this is simply one of the greatest cigars in current production anywhere in the world. I have smoked them with a bit of age on them and I have smoked them straight off the boat from Cuba and they never disappoint. They burn beautifully, look fantastic and represent everything that I love about Cuban cigars. People talk about the balance of a cigar all the time, but the Monte 2 holds so many complimentary flavours and develops so naturally as you smoke it that 'well balanced' doesn't really do it justice. This is a harmonious cigar...


The flagship of the Montscristo brand also manages to be the standard bearer for the Piramede size and hold its own as one of the great Cuban smokes in the marketplace. Put simply, the Monte 2 is the most iconic cigar in the world today.


10/10.


Published in
Fri, 01/08/2010 - 15:42
#1
Al
Posts: 45

Jimmy
I love what you have written here, but have to be honest I would choose the Partagas P2 over the Monte these days. It just seems to deliver more flavour.

It might be a bit of a'johnny-come-lately' by your standards but we are all experts of our personal taste.

Nice to finally see some reviews going up here.

Mon, 02/15/2010 - 13:54
#2
CharlieJ
Posts: 5

I've always loved the Monte 2 as well Jimmy, and i agree with your review.

Has the Edmundo improved a lot in the last year or so, I hear that the early ones lacked a lot of punch, but the newer releases were better. Would you rather buy a box of Monte 2's or recent release Edmundo's?

Cheers Charlie

Fri, 02/19/2010 - 11:33
#3
Jimmy McGhee
Posts: 322

Hi Al,

The P2 is a cracking smoke and right up there, but the monti 2 is a cigar to which I always seem to return. I don't think this has anything to do with how long they have been on the market as I have smoked some fresh Monti 2s and enjoyed them hugely. It is just a cigar that resonates with me personally.

Charlie, in answer to your question, I would always go for the Monti 2. That's not to say the Edmundo isn't a great smoke (I like the Petit Edmundo just as much), but the No2 holds a very special place in my heart and will take some shifting.

Can I assume you would rather go for the Edmundo?

Mon, 03/08/2010 - 17:14
#4
CharlieJ
Posts: 5

Jimmy,
I have never had an Edmundo before but have enjoyed many Petit Edmundo's. I was always been put off the Edmundo by everyone saying that it's little brother was superior.

Is the blend very different bewtween the Monte 2 and the Edmundo? They are very similar sizes and was wondering if torcedores got the same batch of tobacco but just made them into different shapes?

Charlie

Tue, 03/30/2010 - 07:59
#5
Henry Longfoot
Posts: 35

I always found the Edmundo a bit lighter than the No2. The general answer is that the blend will be the same through out the range, but the different sizes produce a different smoking experience. I suppose I'm lucky, 'cause I love 'em both!

HL

Tue, 03/30/2010 - 23:18
#6
laficion
Posts: 15

Thank you Jimmy for a review on a fine Monty 2 that you love and enjoy .
As for me, I've never been a big Monty Fan but I do smoke the Piramid shape.
My fav is the H.Upmann No. 2 which I find simply wounderful in it's flavour profile,
Rich, bold and well balenced, always a pleasure.

I guess the important thing is to enjoy what you smoke.

Fri, 04/02/2010 - 10:36
#7
kung fu panda
Posts: 23

good shout laficion, upmann 2 is a fav of mine....getting harder to find though....are they one of the ones that have been discontinued?

Sat, 04/03/2010 - 00:02
#8
laficion
Posts: 15

No Kung Fu, I'm sure they are not being
discontinued, I'm sure that you'll be able to find them. Good hunting, LOL

Sat, 04/03/2010 - 23:49
#9
AZCigarNut
Posts: 22

No these aren't on the discontinued list. I'd cry myself to sleep. :)

Tue, 04/06/2010 - 09:09
#10
Al
Posts: 45

As far as I can see the Upmann No2 is still in production. It is not mentioned on any of the D-lists in circulation. You can check out the discontinued UK cigar list on this site here. I'm not a massive fan of the cigar personally, but I would be very surprised to see this one go

Search

Search for content with our pages or blogs. Just enter a keyword below.

Club Members

Tardisbasher's picture
NxtCent1's picture
Wilfredo Diaz's picture
Jabe Culbreth's picture
psp's picture
El Gringo's picture
shotgun's picture
markovicale's picture
cjtech's picture
alexkanias's picture
koen's picture
spud2's picture
Bowen Whiteoak's picture
dreadary's picture
chris p's picture
David Rosenberg's picture
singerisland's picture
Marilyn Perez Uncal's picture
jk2607's picture
MAXIMUS's picture
Phil's picture
keith.marsden@hotmail.com's picture
FatCat's picture
aalzayani's picture
eray's picture
TOAR's picture
Kenneth Thompson's picture
AZCigarNut's picture
gecko's picture
Serie 1974's picture

Cigar Selector


Why Join The Cigar Smokers Club?

Become a member of the Cigar Smokers Club and enjoy the benefits of having unlimited access to vast amounts of cigar information, ranging from brand information to the history of cigars themselves. You will have access to the latest news, first, or all new product news, events and new cigars. There are Regular blogs written by industry figureheads such as Simon Chase which you can directly comment on or discuss in our forums.
1)Chat in our Forums
4)Comment on Blogs
2)Upload Photos
5)Shop
3)View Events
6)Recieve our Newsletters